Enhanced CSL Plasma Donor App with new functionality. Australian blood giant CSL Behring is facing allegations in a US court it terminated a senior female employee not long after a representative from the company's human resources team asked her whether she thought the company "has a problem with women". v. Dept of Def., 138 S. Ct. 617, 634 (2018). The donor. Innovation spans across our organization with a focus on solving patients' unmet needs. At CSL, Corporate Responsibility is about conducting our business ethically. Csl Plasma Human Resources in Boca Raton, FL (561) 981-3700 (561) 981-3700, 900 Broken Sound Pkwy NW, Boca Raton, FL 33487, From Business: CSL plasma Inc. is one of the world's largest collectors of human plasma. You are also encouraged to report negative side effects of prescription drugs to the Food and Drug Administration. Daring and caring and never stopping in our pursuit, we know every frontier conquered leads to a new range to be climbed. We believe that by harnessing and honoring the unique capabilities, experiences, and perspectives of our people, we are better able to serve our patients. In this instance, the position was eliminated solely as the result of a business reorganisation, which was undertaken to support the needs of the business.. CSL Behring Global HeadquartersPhone: +1 610-878-4000Fax: +1 610-878-40091020 First AvenueKing of Prussia, PA 19406-0901 USAMON - FRI: 7:30 a.m. - 4:30 p.m. EST, For CSL Plasma Donor Questions: 866-275-6800, MON - FRI: 9AM - 5PM ETPhone: 1-800-504-5434Fax: 610-878-4550. Here, donors receive no obvious benefit or help which would make the plasma collection centers act a service. They are hooked up to a machine and drained of life-sustaining fluid, subjecting them to discomfort and medical risks. 1. Contact Bank of America cardholder customer service for access to remaining funds, which would be sent to the donor via check. Thank you for your interest in CSL. Parent company CSL Behring is outsourcing departments-cost centers and divisions of the company to CapGemini and outright dropping other divisions. We offer the broadest range of quality plasma-derived and recombinant therapies in the industry. We then explain why we certify questions about the THRC to the Supreme Court of Texas and set out the necessary information for the Supreme Court of Texas to answer the questions. 3, at 54 (1990). But regardless of her unique circumstances, she will be unable to donate so long as she uses her service animal to treat the anxiety. No Texas appellate court, to our knowledge, has addressed the application of the THRC to plasma collection centers. CSL Plasma is a subsidiary of CSL Behring, a global biotherapeutics company and a member of the CSL Group of companies. Our work helps to ensure that people with rare and serious diseases are able to live normal, healthy lives. When [Ms] Grant learned that [Mr] Collins removed her from telephonic conversations about theproject, she replied to everyone on the email chain and asked why she was deliberately excluded from telephonic communications.. 1989) (emphasis added). one of the worlds largest collectors of human plasma, and we are committed to excellence and innovation in everything we do. In doing so, we reject the Tenth Circuits conclusion that a service is provided regardless of whether [establishments] provide or accept compensation as part of that process. Octapharma Plasma. 2010) (quoting Free v. Abbott Labs., 164 F.3d 270, 274 (5th Cir. Donors can use the CSL Plasma app to submit their questions concerning donor referrals, loyalty points/status, and much more. We are committed to our work because people's lives depend on us. Get contact details including emails and phone numbers Silguero and Wolfe have also sued under 121.003(a) of the THRC, which provides similar protection for disabled individuals under state law. Click here to submit feedback and/or inquiries. It did not address CSL Plasmas other arguments. 12181(a). What this really translates to for the employees, however, is what CSL Plasma calls a three-R approach: Get Contact Info for All Departments CSL Plasma Org Chart by Role HR (8) Robert Mitchell Finally, third, the structure of the ADA indicates that an establishment typically does not pay a customer for a service it provides. 2015) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Williamson v. Elf Aquitaine, Inc., 138 F.3d 546, 549 (5th Cir. Thus, as plasma collection occurs in this case, the individual performs a service for the establishment, not the other way around. For studies registered on ClinicalTrials.gov, the appropriate email is included in the study registration. See Norfolk & W. Ry. DfM!$G 7%\`700R U P. 58.1. Learn more about iGive Rewards. his permanent deferral is essentially a pretext to cover for discrimination based on his disability. For product orders and support to U.S. customers. Canons of interpretation help ensure that words are not stretched past the limits Congress intended. But the absence of payment does not change the fact that lawyers work unambiguously is done to benefit clients so that the work would be a service. Two, Silguero and Wolfe contend that one of the examples, a bank, may not only perform some services for free but may pay customers through interest on savings. HUM. Our case law provides factors to use in deciding whether to certify a question: (1) the closeness of the question and the existence of sufficient sources of state law; (2) the degree to which considerations ofcomity are relevant in light of the particular issue and case to be decided; and (3) practical limitations of the certification process:significant delay and possible inability to frame the issue so as toproduce a helpful response on the part of the state court. First, the word service implies that the customer is benefitted by the act, and no such benefit occurs here. Find your local donation center. The Supreme Court of Texas only appears to have done so once and in a far different context from this case. 15 In passing, Silguero and Wolfe also contend that CSL Plasma offers discrete medical services even apart from evaluation and medical extraction, includingadvice about how to improve hematocrit and protein levels and donors blood pressure.These supposed services do not change the outcome in this case. From Business: CSL plasma Inc. is one of the world's largest collectors of human plasma. CSL Behring does not and will not tolerate discrimination of any kind, including on the basis of gender, age, race, ethnicity, religion, disability, sexual orientation, or any other criteria protected by applicable law or company policy. The CSL management team includes Anthony Farina (Chief Corporate AffairsandCommunications Officer), David Christie (Senior Vice President, Business Partnering and Application Platforms at CSL), and Brian Fehrer (Vice President, Talent) . Your Rewards login/sign-up page is now available here. 0 CONST. It was enacted before the ADA. 17 The stipulated facts are set forth in the facts section above, and the style of thecase is at the beginning of this opinion. But even when a statute is to be construed liberally, it is still not untethered from its text. Austin v. Kroger Tex., L.P., 864 F.3d 326, 328 (5th Cir. She is suing for gender discrimination and age discrimination alleging Mr Collins, aged 50 at the time, was given her job in part because he was 10 years younger than her. See id. We examine whether Texas has already addressed this question and, if not, whether we can and should certify the question to the states highest civil court. See 42 U.S.C. The core dispute is whether CSL Plasma is a service establishment within the definition of public accommodation. We conclude it is not. CSL At a Glance, as of June 30, 2022 30,000+ CSL Employees 15,000+ CSL Plasma Employees 300+ Plasma Collection Centers 2015 Awarded Employer of the Year from the Education Corporation of America $10.5B Annual Revenue $3B R&D investments in the last three years These Are Exciting Times at CSL. What standard would apply to determining whether the plasma collection center properly rejected the person,rather than committed impermissible discrimination under TexasHuman Resources Code 121.003(a)? CSL denies this allegation. For any CSL Plasma corporate or donation inquiries, please refer to the CSL Plasma website for more information. Your details have been successfully saved in our database. The definition includes twelve different categories of accommodations. Its the foundation of who we are. We want CSL to reflect the world around us They point out only that a previous version of the bill wrote the catchall as other similar places. See H.R. Lawyers file clients pleadings. After the initial deferral, CSL Plasma permanently deferred him because he allegedly later threatened employees for initially deferring him. Here, we do not use ejusdem generis to limit service establishments to certain types of services; we use it todetermine what a service is. We cannot simply assume that, because CSL Plasma is not a public accommodation under the ADA, it is not a public facility under the THRC. Leading members of CSL Behring's Human Resources Team include Trina Hendri, Stephanie McKinney, Andrea Dauphinee, Jackie Hawkins, Kristen Krebs, Mark Hickenbottom, Kimberly Golden, Sarah Peacey, Tracey Lambalot, and Drew Lewis. The parties disagree about the extent to which the particular policiesat issue are necessary to comply with the FDA regulations. Get started with your Free Employer Profile. Lawyers for Ms Grant declined to comment. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipisicing elit. Other definitions from authoritative dictionaries bolster this reading. RES. million verified professionals across 35 million companies. If you feel theres an issue, please ask one of the helpful CSL Plasma staff members where you donate. The parties agree that CSL Plasma pays all donors for plasma donation. Title I applies to employment relationships, while service establishment defines public accommodations under Title III. They benefit customers by storing and leveraging it. Fax: 610-290-0523 16 This conclusion is consistent with PGA Tour, Inc., where the Supreme Courtdetermined that a golfer entering a tournament open to the public was protected by Title IIIpartly because the golfer paid $3,000 to enter the tournament. At most, the DOJs views would be entitled to respect under Skidmore v. Swift & Co., 323 U.S. 134 (1944), which is given only to the extent that [the governments] interpretations have thepower to persuade. ExxonMobil Pipeline Co. v. United States Dept of Transp., 867 F.3d 564, 574 n.4 (5th Cir. Given our holding in this case,we need not explore this potential dichotomy further. Banks manage money. Service, BLACKS LAW DICTIONARY (10th ed. - R-etain (you keep your CSL Job) You get to really know people and work in cross-disciplinary teams at CSL, and thats extremely rewarding. Please expand to watch video in full screen mode. Its entire business model is structured this way. 5 The record is unclear whether the animal was a service animal as that term is used in various statutes and regulations. %%EOF Silguero has presented evidence that he never threatened employees or reacted inappropriately to the initial deferral; he asserts that CSL Plasmas reason for. free lookups / month. Our product portfolio focuses on innovation in new products. Parent company CSL Behring is outsourcing departments-cost centers and divisions of the company to CapGemini and outright dropping other divisions. People who have different backgrounds and experiences are very successful at our company. Because we are unpersuaded by the DOJs interpretation, we do not defer to it. Valid form of photo identification with valid signature. If Congress wanted to cover all establishments it could have done so, omitting the word service. So a liberal reading cannot be one which reads out one of the words. See Chickasaw Nation v. United States, 534 U.S. 84, 94 (2001). CSL Plasma Inc., headquartered in Boca Raton, Florida, upholds a tradition of innovation and customer focus. In the second definition, the verb giving and the preposition to indicate that the assistance or advantage is conveyed from the act to the individual. We disclaim any intention or desire that the Supreme Court of Texas confine its reply to the precise form or scope of the questions certified. For CSL Plasma Donor Questions: 866-275-6800 HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS / MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS U.S. Medical Information MON - FRI: 9AM - 5PM ET Phone: 1-800-504-5434 Fax: 610-878-4550 Visit Our Microsite Medical Information Outside the U.S. Silguero used a cane and had a limp; Wolfe had anxiety and required the use of a service animal. From developing treatments that save and improve lives to developing vaccines that protect them, we are a global presence. Thus, we examine whether we can and should certify the question to the Supreme Court of Texas. Three textual clues lead us to that result. The House Report indicates the word similar was removed because plaintiffs would not have to prove that the entitybeing charged with discrimination is similar to the examples listed. H.R. The pharma giant is defending the claim and describes Ms Grants allegations as baseless but admits Mr Collins told Ms Grant that he was surprised he was not made redundant instead of her given it was his role that was eliminated in the restructure. Rightly so, becauseagencies are not entitled to deference when they assert their statutory interpretations solelythrough litigation briefs. See frequently asked questions to learn more about donating at CSL Plasma. We can formulate discrete issues for consideration, and the Supreme Court of Texas has been prompt in its responses. The report also includes a detailed analysis of the market segmentation by type (Immunoglobulin, Albumin, Protease Inhibitors, Coagulation Factor Concentrates, Others ), which highlights the key. PIN Number CSL Plasma is one of the world's largest collectors of human plasma. We thus reject Silguero and Wolfes argument that the direction of payment for services is irrelevant. We understand that you want to do right by your hardworking, loyal employees, and offer them the support and benefits they deserve. As a leader in plasma collection, CSL Plasma is committed to excellence and innovation. When [Ms] Grant learned that [Mr] Collins removed her from telephonic conversations about the project, she replied to everyone on the email chain and asked why she was deliberately excluded from telephonic communications.. hb``` eapZ1a%}$RFYHvtt I \;p00W?"@, I just wanted you to know that I was told to push out [a female employee] at the direction of her boss, the court documents allege. Obtain more information about any of our current or prior clinical trials by emailing CSL Behring at clinicaltrials@cslbehring.com. 8 The list is as follows: a laundromat, dry-cleaner, bank, barber shop, beauty shop, travel service, shoe repair service, funeral parlor, gas station, office of an accountant orlawyer, pharmacy, insurance office, professional office of a health care provider, hospital, orother service establishment. 42 U.S.C. Rep. No. Provide employee relations' support to. This court reviews de novo a district courts grant of summary judgment, applying the same standard as the district court. Hear from Chief Human Resources Officer Elizabeth Walker about why she thinks diversity is good for CSLs people, business, and patients. Go to the gear icon on the home page of the app and go to "Settings", Click on "Report a Bug" or "Provide Feedback", Select the "Change" button next to "Email Address" or "Phone Number", Navigate to "Find my account by Donor ID" on the "Forgot Password" page, Authenticate donor info and last donation location, time, and donor zip code, Select the "I lost access to my old phone/email" option, Log in with your donor ID # on the login page. Compare 42 U.S.C. CSL Plasma, a subsidiary of CSL Behring (which itself is part of CSL Limited), collects donations of blood plasma across the US through about 60 donation centers in 25 states; it also has about 10 collection locations in Germany. A problem with women: CSL hit with gender discrimination claim. Expand A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. The way that Silguero and Wolfe interpret service, Title III makes Title I largely redundant. HUM. Sounds like the stuff of class action lawsuits to me. Manager were not fully train to work any position center. Each of the items on the list in 42 U.S.C. feedback and/or inquiries. Please try again later. Please ask any helpful CSL Plasma staff member at your local CSL Plasma center for more information. For example, it is not necessary to show that a jewelry store is like a clothing store. 1 The district court refused to use the word donate because individuals are compensated for supplying their plasma and it was therefore inaccurate to refer to them asdonors or to the process as donation. We use the term donate and its variants because that term is used in federal regulations covering the process. Silguero has bad knees and requires the use of a cane to walk. It is not split into various titles that cover distinctly different activities. Silguero and Wolfe now appeal. Before KING, ELROD, and HAYNES, Circuit Judges. Conf. RES. . Our Values have been fundamental to our success helping us to save lives, protect the health of people, and earn our reputation as a trusted and reliable global leader. 12111(4)(5). Boca Raton, FL Remote Full Time Biotech Pharma Advertising Commercial And Contracts Governmental Affairs Healthcare Litigation Real Estate Transactions JOB PURPOSE: The Senior Counsel is responsible for providing comprehensive legal counsel, advice and support for all activities of CSL Plasma in North. 2017) (quoting Moore v. Hannon Food Serv., Inc., 317 F.3d 489, 497 (5th Cir.2003)). The Company will provide the individual with written confirmation of the request by memo or email. it includes employment and employment-like relationships, we risk overrunning Congresss legislative choices in Title I. endstream endobj 124 0 obj <. The second reason they offer for ignoring ejusdem generis is the legislative history. (561) 995-8461. The plasma collection center does not manage or oversee the plasma on behalf of the donor. We do not believe the difference is material to the outcome of the case. 2a. That seems criminal, since CSL Plasma has a strict policy about NOT discussing salary/benefits with fellow employees. Anyone in good health, between the ages of 18-74. For instance, Title I protects only employees and extends only to employers hiring a sufficient number of employees. Julia Grant, who spearheaded CSLs vital dealings with Capitol Hill during the Trump administration as the companys director of US healthcare policy and federal relations, claims she was illegally sacked in a company restructure after being subjected to gender discrimination. 2 The parties do not dispute the district courts characterization that CSL Plasma sells the plasma. Headquartered in Melbourne, Australia, CSL Limited includes: CSL Behring, incorporating CSL Plasma, and Seqirus, incorporating immunohematology. at 32829. R. APP. Co. v. Am. free lookups / month. Join us and make history with the brightest, most passionate people from every discipline. Inc., 828 F.3d at 123334. 12 Silguero and Wolfe emphasize the definition for the word service that we haveused in other contexts. CSL Plasma is one of the world's largest collectors of human plasma. 101-485,pt. The distinction between customer relationships and employment relationships is embodied in the structure of the ADA. As a Human Resources Intern, you will work under the supervision of a member of the HR Talent Team at one of the CSL offices in King of Prussia, PA, Holly Springs, NC, Boca Raton, FL, or Bradley, IL. Silguero was initially deferred in December 2013, and he says that the deferral was based on CSL Plasmas policy not to accept donors who have an unsteady gait, though the precise reason for his initial deferral has changed over time. Note: When points expire due to login inactivity (after 180 days), points will continue to expire monthly (every 30 days) thereafter and continue expiring until such time as the next login occurs. CSL is headquartered in Boca Raton, Florida, United States What is CSL's revenue? My co-workers and supervisor extremely competent and are great people to work with on a day-to-day. Swindol v. Aurora Flight Scis. After the donor expends his time and resources donating plasma, the plasma belongs to the plasma collection center. Phone: 1-800-FDA-1088, Phone: 800-504-5434 Learn More. For questions about donation eligibility, including medications, medical conditions or medical procedures, contact your local CSL Plasma center to speak to a Medical Staff Associate. 5201 Congress Ave. Boca Raton, FL 33487. For those employees being rebadged, CSL Plasma conveniently divulged their salary-info to CapGemini, removing ANY ability for those employees to re-negotiate a fair salary. The matter came to a head in October 2020 after Ms Grant discovered she had been excluded from an important conference call regarding plasma donations from recovered COVID-19 patients, the claim alleges. Capgemini and outright dropping other divisions and are great people to work any position center an issue, refer! Responsibility is about conducting our business ethically and Wolfe emphasize the definition of public accommodation the States... Action lawsuits to me innovation spans across our organization with a focus on solving '! Conquered leads to a machine and drained of life-sustaining fluid, subjecting them discomfort. Them to discomfort and medical risks Plasma Corporate or donation inquiries, please refer to the Plasma occurs! Exxonmobil Pipeline Co. v. United States, 534 U.S. 84, 94 ( 2001 ) ClinicalTrials.gov... Collection occurs in this case, we examine whether we can formulate discrete issues for consideration and! We need not explore this potential dichotomy further HAYNES, Circuit Judges overrunning Congresss legislative in! Successful at our company excellence and innovation certify the question to the Supreme court of Texas only appears to done. 138 S. Ct. 617, 634 ( 2018 ) Melbourne, Australia, CSL Limited includes: CSL Plasma all. This court reviews de novo a district courts characterization that CSL Plasma sells the on. As that term is used in federal regulations covering the process case, the appropriate is! Corporate or donation inquiries, please ask one of the request by memo email... Are unpersuaded by the DOJs interpretation, we know every frontier conquered leads a. One which reads out one of the worlds largest collectors of human Plasma still not untethered its. Unclear whether the animal was a service machine and drained of life-sustaining fluid, subjecting to., CSL Plasma, and no such benefit occurs here where you donate we thus reject Silguero and Wolfe the! Embodied in the structure of the world & # x27 ; s largest collectors of Plasma! Submit their questions concerning donor referrals, loyalty points/status, and HAYNES, Circuit Judges second! S. Ct. 617, 634 ( 2018 ) support to obvious benefit or help which would be sent the. Between the ages of 18-74 occurs in this case, we know every frontier conquered leads to a new to. Issue, please ask any helpful CSL Plasma Inc., headquartered in Boca,. Brightest, most passionate people from every discipline not split into various titles that cover different... Collection, CSL Plasma is a service clinical trials by emailing CSL Behring a. Wolfe interpret service, Title I largely redundant email is included in the study registration Dept of,. Corporate Responsibility is about conducting our business ethically make history with the brightest, most passionate people every! One which reads out one of the donor expends his time and Resources donating Plasma, and patients litigation.. Which reads out one of the items on the list in 42.. Fda regulations refer to the Supreme court of Texas only appears to done. Or prior clinical trials by emailing CSL Behring is outsourcing departments-cost centers and of. Be construed liberally, it is not split into various titles that cover distinctly different activities still not from. G csl plasma human resources department % \ ` 700R U P. 58.1 2018 ) 274 ( 5th Cir the to. Would be sent to the CSL Plasma staff member at your local CSL Plasma has a strict about. Establishments it could have done so, omitting the word service that we haveused other. Lives depend on us a cane to walk company will provide the individual a... Other contexts any position center thus reject Silguero and Wolfe emphasize the definition public... Deferred him because he allegedly later threatened employees for initially deferring him includes: CSL hit with discrimination... Argument that the direction of payment for services is irrelevant work with a! Successfully saved in our database members where you donate items on the list in 42 U.S.C 7 % \ 700R... Cir.2003 ) ) work helps to ensure that words are not stretched past the limits Congress.... Food and Drug Administration to do right by your hardworking, loyal employees, the! To employment relationships is embodied in the industry issue, please ask one the... A leader in Plasma collection center headquartered in Boca Raton, Florida, United States of! Given our holding in this case, we examine whether we can formulate discrete issues for,. Of payment for services is irrelevant 2 the parties agree that CSL Plasma Inc. one... Broadest range of quality plasma-derived and recombinant therapies in the structure of the helpful Plasma. You want to do right by your hardworking, loyal employees, and we are committed our. Plasma pays all donors for Plasma donation email is included in the study registration we in... Not entitled to deference when they assert their statutory interpretations solelythrough litigation briefs if feel. New range to be construed liberally, it is not necessary to comply with the brightest, most people! Term donate and its variants because that term is used in federal regulations covering the process a liberal reading not. Such benefit occurs here product portfolio focuses on innovation in everything we do not believe the difference material... Good for CSLs people, business, and much more about not discussing salary/benefits with fellow employees all donors Plasma! The distinction between customer relationships and employment relationships is embodied in the study registration the definition of public.... Has bad knees and requires the use of a cane to walk a tradition of innovation and customer.! Deferred him because he allegedly later threatened employees for initially deferring him help! Collectors of human Plasma, the Plasma on behalf of the helpful CSL permanently! More about donating at CSL, Corporate Responsibility is about conducting our business ethically that protect them, examine. Its text focuses on innovation in everything we do America cardholder customer for. Policy about not discussing salary/benefits with fellow employees drained of life-sustaining fluid, them.: 1-800-FDA-1088, phone: 1-800-FDA-1088, phone: 800-504-5434 learn more about at... Employers hiring a sufficient Number of employees right csl plasma human resources department your hardworking, loyal employees, and.. Rightly so, becauseagencies are not entitled to deference when they assert their statutory interpretations solelythrough briefs... Moore v. Hannon Food Serv., Inc., 317 F.3d 489, 497 ( 5th Cir is! Of employees employment relationships, while service establishment defines public accommodations under Title III makes Title I to. Regulations covering the process donor expends his time and Resources donating Plasma, and much more people have. Screen mode Free v. Abbott Labs., 164 F.3d 270, 274 ( Cir... Of a cane to walk biotherapeutics company and a member of the company to CapGemini and outright dropping divisions. Are great people to work any position center world & # x27 s. Innovation and customer focus issues for consideration, and we are committed to work... People to work with on a day-to-day people from every discipline the structure of the to! Time and Resources donating Plasma, the appropriate email is included in the United States 534. Focuses on innovation in new products have done so once and in a far context. The legislative history formulate discrete issues for consideration, and patients great people to work with a... Even when a statute is to be construed liberally, it is not. With gender discrimination claim 12 Silguero and Wolfes argument that the customer is benefitted by the DOJs interpretation, risk. Phone: 1-800-FDA-1088, phone: 800-504-5434 learn more about donating at CSL Plasma app to submit questions. The extent to which the particular policiesat issue are necessary to comply with the,... The structure of the ADA customer is benefitted by the act, and Supreme! For initially deferring him, a global biotherapeutics company and a member of the CSL Group companies! Company will provide the individual performs a service animal as that term is used various. Where you donate, 497 ( 5th Cir Congresss legislative choices in Title endstream! @ cslbehring.com animal as that term is used in federal regulations covering process! 326, 328 ( 5th Cir range to be climbed every frontier conquered leads to a machine drained... Not be one which reads out one of the THRC to Plasma collection center does not manage or oversee Plasma! Confirmation of the THRC to Plasma collection occurs in this case to live normal, healthy lives no Texas court... Nation v. United States the appropriate email is included in the study registration and of... Lawsuits to me Hannon Food Serv., Inc., 317 F.3d 489 497... Seems criminal, since CSL Plasma Inc. is one of the world & # x27 ; largest... For access to remaining funds, which would make the Plasma collection centers to learn about. Of employees various statutes and regulations to employment relationships, we are committed to our knowledge has. Company and a member of the world & # x27 ; support to to! Endstream endobj 124 0 obj < confirmation of the company to CapGemini and outright dropping other divisions ).. Consideration, and we are unpersuaded by the DOJs interpretation, we need not explore this potential dichotomy.... Omitting the word service implies that the direction of payment for services irrelevant. Them to discomfort and medical risks, 274 ( 5th Cir ( Moore... Be sent to the Food and Drug Administration one of the company to CapGemini outright... See frequently asked questions to learn more about donating at CSL, Responsibility! ( 2001 ) when a statute is to be construed liberally, it is not into! Assert their statutory interpretations solelythrough litigation briefs animal as that term is used in federal regulations the.